Understanding the Arab Digital Generation

The Arab Digital Generation, a tech-savvy demographic born between 1977 and 1997, accounts for 40% of the MENA population and is distinguishing itself economically, socially, and politically. The paper, produced by Strategy& and Google, looks at this generation’s potential impact.

Show transcript

Understanding the Arab Digital Generation

Strategy& is part of the PwC network

Contacts

Strategy& Beirut Bahjat El-Darwiche Partner +961-1-985-655 bahjat.eldarwiche @strategyand.pwc.com Walid Tohme Partner +961-1-985-655 walid.tohme @strategyand.pwc.com Dubai Jan Schmitz-Huebsch Principal +971-4-390-0260 jan.schmitz-huebsch @strategyand.pwc.com Milind Singh Principal +971-4-390-0260 milind.singh @strategyand.pwc.com Riyadh Hilal Halaoui Partner +966-1-249-7781 hilal.halaoui @strategyand.pwc.com

Google Dubai Mohamad Mourad Regional Manager +971-5-0616-0685 mmourad@google.com Wassim Kabbara Industry Manager, Gulf Region +971-5-0556-7639 wassim@google.com

This report was previously published as “Understanding the Arab Digital Generation,” by Karim Sabbagh, Mohamad Mourad, Wassim Kabbara, Ramez T. Shehadi, and Hatem Samman (2012: Booz & Company).

2

Strategy&

About the authors

About Strategy& Strategy& is a global team of practical strategists committed to helping you seize essential advantage. We do that by working alongside you to solve your toughest problems and helping you capture your greatest opportunities. These are complex and high-stakes undertakings — often game-changing transformations. We bring 100 years of strategy consulting experience and the unrivaled industry and functional capabilities of the PwC network to the task. Whether you’re charting your corporate strategy, transforming a function or business unit, or building critical capabilities, we’ll help you create the value you’re looking for with speed, confidence, and impact. We are a member of the PwC network of firms in 157 countries with more than 195,000 people committed to delivering quality in assurance, tax, and advisory services. Tell us what matters to you and find out more by visiting us at strategyand.pwc.com/me. We want to thank Mohamad Mourad and Wassim Kabbara from Google for their contributions to this report.

About the Ideation Center The Ideation Center is Strategy&’s leading think tank in the Middle East. We provide thought leadership through insightful research, analysis, and dialogue that is true to the Middle East dynamics. We bring these ideas to the forefront through our publications and website.

Strategy&

3

Executive summary

A new generation is emerging in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region. Born between 1977 and 1997, this demographic is 40 percent of the MENA population. A growing number of them are extremely active online and in social networks. They are the Arab Digital Generation (ADG). Digital technology gives the ADG the potential to affect society and institutions in unprecedented ways. To better understand the ADG, Booz & Company (now Strategy&), in partnership with Google, surveyed more than 3,000 digital users in nine countries. The results portray how digital technology is influencing the ADG and giving it the potential to shape the region in turn. Although technology is also affecting other young people around the globe, the Arab world is more susceptible to widespread change, due to demographics and the region’s strong behavioral norms. The survey results show the impact of technology on society. The ADG is developing its own, less traditional ideas about family, religion, and marriage. The results also point to implications for sectors critical for socioeconomic development: 1) government, where the ADG has high expectations for transparency and e-government services; 2) the private sector, where the ADG’s significant buying potential is untapped; 3) education, where the ADG wants digital upgrades and new teaching tools as preparation for the job market; and 4) healthcare, where the ADG feels that providers can leverage new technology to improve access to care, along with quality and cost. In sum, the ADG is distinguishing itself economically, socially, and politically from earlier generations. For policymakers, business and community leaders, and educators, this group represents an important change and potential opportunity. Those who wish to capitalize on the promise of the ADG must take active steps to better understand it and the digital world that it inhabits. If not, they risk increasing the digital divide, which can have serious socioeconomic implications in a global economy.

4

Strategy&

Digital lifestyle: How the Arab Digital Generation uses technology
• 83 percent use the Internet daily • 40 percent use the Internet for at least five hours a day • 61 percent spend more than two hours per day on social networking sites • 78 percent prefer the Internet to TV • 54 percent have higher education levels; this proportion is higher for women (60 percent) than men (49 percent) • 16 percent access the Internet from schools or academic institutions; 76 percent access it from home • 63 percent express a desire for freedom to do and say what they want as long as it does not harm others • 37 percent say they can freely express their opinions without fear of the consequences • 53 percent research companies and products online, and 51 percent spread the word about their experiences with companies — both good and bad • 37 percent believe that technology has reduced family communication and cohesion • 41 percent search the Internet in both Arabic and English; 21 percent chat in both languages • 48 percent are not satisfied with the quality of local websites; 47 percent are not satisfied with local versions of international websites • 37 percent are not satisfied with the availability of Arabic websites • 46 percent of unmarried ADG members expect to choose for themselves whom they will marry • 8 percent use an online platform to connect with government or political leaders

Strategy&

5

• 31 percent cited lack of trust in leaders and fear of being targeted as the main reasons for not communicating with political leaders • 42 percent do not buy products online because they prefer to deal with a person; 38 percent worry about website security • 48 percent believe that the region’s healthcare services require technological upgrades; 43 percent believe this of education services • 56 percent of those unemployed cited lack of opportunities for work • 40 percent stated that education does not prepare students for the job market • 43 percent of ADG members would like to start their own business; just 3 percent want to work for a local company with no international presence • 24 percent believe that media content is totally controlled by government

(From the Booz & Company –Google Arab Digital Generation survey 2012)

6

Strategy&

A new generation

Advances in information and communications technology (ICT) are shaping a new generation in the MENA region, one that is far different from its predecessors. Today, young people increasingly conduct their lives online. They use digital technology to socialize with their friends and to browse online for products and services (though they are reluctant to purchase online). They upload YouTube videos to express themselves, voice their social and political beliefs, and broadcast local events for the entire world to watch. Digital technology is therefore helping this generation differentiate itself from previous generations in several ways. These young people are far more active as consumers and as critics. They are more directly involved than their parents in the media they consume and purchase, and they are more outspoken about society, economics, and politics. Their social and business networks — through Facebook, Google+, LinkedIn, blogs, and other media venues — are providing new socioeconomic and civic platforms, requiring society and institutions to reinvent current business and policy models. We call this demographic segment the Arab Digital Generation, or ADG (which we define as people ages 15 to 35 who are consistent users of technology). Although they have similar digital characteristics as other young people around the world, they are distinctly Arab in that they reflect the traditions, challenges, and tribulations of their region, along with a strong desire to make changes. This parallels a similar evolution in other regions, as digital technology is becoming more pervasive. More people have access to a mobile phone today than to electricity.1 The sheer volume of information online is increasing in a nonlinear fashion. Cisco estimates that mobile data traffic will increase eighteen-fold between 2011 and 2016, to 10.8 exabytes (an exabyte is 1018 bytes or 1,000 petabytes).2 This growth tends to be concentrated in developing economies. For example, the Internet user base in China surpassed 384 million in 2009, more than in both the U.S. and Japan combined. Current projections call for that number to reach 650 million by 2015. Moreover, Internet usage is consistently higher among younger and more educated people. Roughly half of 16- to 24-year-olds in
Strategy&

Digital technology is therefore helping this generation differentiate itself from previous generations in several ways. These young people are far more active as consumers and as critics.

7

Europe are savvy users of social networks. The World Internet Project, which analyzes online usage patterns, found that roughly half of the respondents in most countries analyzed were regular Internet users, and more than 80 percent of young people regularly went online.3 Yet although technology is driving social, civic, and economic shifts worldwide, the MENA region has perhaps more propensity to embody these changes than elsewhere, for several reasons. First, young people — who have greater adoption rates for new technology — make up a larger portion of the overall population. From 2006 to 2011 the number of Internet users in Arab countries has been growing by 23 percent annually.4 World Internet users, by comparison, have grown by only 14 percent annually.5 In addition, the region is undergoing a strong urbanization trend, and urban dwellers are similarly more likely to use technology. At the same time, the MENA region has seen extremely rapid growth in ICT infrastructure. Over the past five to seven years, no other part of the world has advanced as rapidly. Through investments in telecommunications infrastructure, digital readiness initiatives, and competitive arrangements for network providers, the region has closed the digital gap with North America, Europe, and Asia. The Networked Readiness Index of the 2012 Global Information Technology Report ranked three Arab countries in the top 30. In the United Nations’ e-Government Survey 2012, the United Arab Emirates (UAE) was among the top third of 190 countries in telecommunications infrastructure index value, along with Qatar, Saudi Arabia, and Bahrain.6 There are cultural factors at work, as well. In the past, this region has been governed by a strong set of traditional structures, such as family, religion, and societal norms. Younger people relied on these structures to guide them and tell them how to live their lives. Now, digital technology offers another source of information, which can upend those traditional structures (or reinforce them for organizations that can adapt and connect with these young people). In this way, the ADG represents a potentially greater disruption — and a potentially greater opportunity — to society and institutions throughout the MENA region than similar groups pose in other regions. Just as the ADG is altering the Arab socioeconomic and political landscape, these people expect changes in return. They are different from young people in other parts of the world, in that they are actively seeking — indeed struggling — to build an identity for themselves distinct from previous generations. This new identity will permeate all aspects of society: relationships with friends and family, political spheres, consumer behavior, and religion.

The MENA region has seen extremely rapid growth in ICT infrastructure. Over the past five to seven years, no other part of the world has advanced as rapidly.

8

Strategy&

To understand this generation and how it is being shaped by technology, Booz & Company (now Strategy&) collaborated with Google on a survey of more than 3,000 members of the ADG. The survey included both qualitative and quantitative aspects (see “Survey methodology”, page 10). The results give a clear snapshot of this generation and its evolving beliefs. Moreover, our results point to several clear indicators for policymakers; business leaders; and those who oversee religious, education, and healthcare organizations. For example, members of the ADG seek better and more secure connectivity in order to buy products and financial services. They also expect better public services such as e-education initiatives. And they expect more transparency from government agencies and officials. Policymakers and business leaders who wish to engage with this generation must understand their use of digital technology and implement needed development and reform across society and institutions. This Ideation Center report looks at the ADG’s impact on society and each of these institutions in turn, and makes specific policy recommendations following each section. Leaders in the MENA region should view this oncoming change as positive. Through communications and technology, the ADG will help shape the future of industries and society, capturing economic and social value to ensure the growth and stability of the region as a whole.

What is the Arab Digital Generation?
The ADG’s members are Internet users ages 15 to 35 who are digitally active; own a laptop, computer, or smartphone; access the Internet multiple times each day; and have at least one account on a social network. They are educated and independent; they are decidedly religious yet also free-spirited. They are politically aware, if not politically active. They are aligned with general Islamic principles and country/family traditions and culture, but they are constantly questioning tradition and its effect on their lives. Family still represents their most important social unit, and friends are a source of counsel for many decisions. Through the digital world, women — particularly in some cultures of the MENA region — now have a platform to express themselves, share their ideas, and interact with men in virtual space. In previous generations, interaction with men and the outside world was limited. This generation has grown up during a time of political turmoil in the region. They have witnessed or heard about the 1991 Gulf War, have watched the attacks of 9/11 and military operations in Afghanistan and Iraq, and have been exposed to the more visible forms of religious extremism. They have participated in one form or another in the Arab Spring. They are very much affected by Western culture and are wary of its effect on themselves, their children, and future generations.

Strategy&

9

Survey methodology
Booz & Company (now Strategy&) and Google commissioned YouGov, a research and polling firm, to conduct the their joint Arab Digital Generation survey, which occurred in two distinct phases. During the qualitative phase, YouGov conducted eight two-hour focus groups in Saudi Arabia, the UAE, Egypt, and Jordan. These were followed by online community discussion groups in Saudi Arabia, the UAE, and Egypt, each lasting three days. The sample comprised respondents who accessed the Internet at least three to four times a week (for an average of at least 30 minutes each day); owned a smartphone, computer, or laptop; and had at least one account on a social network. The main quantitative study was a combination of online and face-to-face interviews, which took place from June 12 to July 22, 2012. The total sample was 3,127 responses spanning nine countries including Saudi Arabia (436), UAE (Emiratis: 322, Western expatriates: 172), Egypt (420), Bahrain (255), Kuwait (244), Qatar (246), Jordan (302), Algeria (395), and Lebanon (335). The respondents were split roughly equally by age (47 percent of respondents were between 15 and 24, and 53 percent were between 25 and 35) and gender (53 percent of respondents were male, and 47 percent were female).

Policymakers and business leaders who wish to engage with this generation must understand their use of digital technology and implement needed development and reform across society and institutions.

10

Strategy&

Characteristics of the Arab Digital Generation
We looked at the ADG through several lenses, examining demographic, technographic (analyzing their usage of digital technology), and psychographic factors. Demographics The ADG represents a growing portion of the world’s digitally active users. We estimate the digitally active Arab Internet users ages 15 to 35 to number 10 million — nearly 4 percent of the currently estimated 260 million digitally active users worldwide.7 Digitally active users are a microcosm of the broader Arab youth population. This group is expected to rise to 13 million by 2014 — a rise of 11 percent annually, compared to only 7 percent for the world (see Exhibit 1, page 12). Notably, this digitally active generation — part of a larger group ranging between 15 to 35 years of age, which represents over 40 percent of the current Middle East population — is growing fast and will continue to do so in the future. Indeed, by 2030 this age group will be among the largest such demographic segments in the world, at 38 percent of the total Middle East population. That is on par with Asia and higher than North America and Europe. This implies that the number of digitally active users is likely to grow relatively faster than the rest of the world. This demographic phenomenon is important because it amplifies the social, economic, and political stakes in the region. A larger population of young, impassioned people who rely on technology has the potential to trigger proportionally greater changes across society and institutions. The ADG is also highly educated, which also drives greater technology use. Among those not currently in university, more than half have already earned their degree. The vast majority of the ADG is either still studying or has recently completed its degree. One in six ADG members is a full-time college student (primarily at state-funded institutions). Among nonstudents, a majority (54 percent) have university degrees. The percentage is higher for women (at 60 percent) than men (49 percent).
Strategy& 11

A larger population of young, impassioned people who rely on technology has the potential to trigger proportionally greater changes across society and institutions.

Exhibit 1 The Arab Digital Generation is growing fast and will continue to do so
Digital Penetration and Growth Rates Worldwide

Digital Generation (DG) penetration (2011)

Overall DG (millions) +7% 318 27

Population Penetration Ages 15 to 35 Connect Digitally to the Internet Active 15–35 Age Group Penetration

10%

8%

12 13

4%

4%

3%

1%

1%

Population

35%

10 10 15

260

20 19 11% 118

28%

15% 11%

8% Arab States

94 3% 3% Other Middle East and Africa1 43 70 2011 47 81 2014

South East Asia

North America

Latin America

Europe

MEA1 Asia Arab States Latin America South East Asia North America Europe

Asia

Middle East and Africa excluding the 22 Arab League member states.
1

Source: Econsultancy, “Middle East and North Africa Digital Consumer Report”; research into media consumption and habits of MENA Internet users conducted by Effective Measure in conjunction with Spot On PR (September 2010); Euromonitor; Informa; Strategy& analysis

12

Strategy&

However, these people are not finding employment opportunities commensurate with their education. Youth unemployment in the MENA region in 2011 was 27 percent for those ages 15 to 24 — the highest in the world for this age group, and more than double the global average. Among the entire universe of respondents (who span in age from 15 to 35), approximately half are working. This disconnect between education level and employment level is troubling. If policymakers in the region do not take strong steps to create better economic opportunities for these young people, then this young generation will agitate for structural changes in the economy, or they will simply leave for other countries that can offer them greater potential employment opportunities. Considering marital status, most respondents (65 percent) have never been married, a third (32 percent) are married, and a minority (just 3 percent) are divorced, separated, or widowed. Interestingly, 56 percent of those who are divorced, separated, or widowed have on average one child or fewer — a stark contrast to the typically large average family size in the MENA region, which is double that of Western countries. Egypt and Kuwait, for example, have an average household size of about 4.4 and 10, respectively, whereas in the U.S. and the U.K., the figures stand at 3.2 and 2.0, respectively.8 Technographics For the ADG, life without digital technology is unthinkable. Overall usage levels are high — an impressive 83 percent of all survey respondents use the Internet daily. Another 11 percent use it at least five to six days per week. Internet usage differs across clusters, with countries in the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC; Bahrain, Kuwait, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, and the UAE in our survey) reporting slightly lower than average daily usage. This is in line with recent literature about Internet usage patterns. A 2011 Strategy& study of youth in the region found that surfing the Internet was the most popular leisure activity in the region, and one in four respondents spent at least 10 hours a week online.9 The technology behavior of the ADG can be depicted along two dimensions: online activities, and the platforms they use to access the Internet. Purpose of usage The most important reason for accessing the Internet is personal entertainment, such as online movies, blogs, or social media. These are preferred to the detriment of TV, radio, and print newspapers. By contrast, the professional use of the Internet, such as for business, academic purposes, or personal administrative tasks like paying bills, is more limited. These represent missed opportunities for education and economic interactions.

If policymakers in the region do not take strong steps to create better economic opportunities for these young people, then this young generation will agitate for structural changes in the economy, or they will simply leave for other countries that can offer them greater potential employment opportunities.

Strategy&

13

Entertainment activities Entertainment activities in the MENA region are popular across all clusters (see Exhibit 2). Social activities are high on the list of interests — nearly two-thirds of respondents spend between one and three hours on social networking sites each day. The majority of users across all regions rarely or never pay to download media.

Exhibit 2 Online entertainment is popular with the ADG

Frequency of Online Entertainment Activities

GCC 42% 19% 18%

Levant 41%

North Africa 32% 47% 31%

Daily

16%

27%

29%

25%

22%

Weekly

24%

32%

37%

27%

18%

32%

31%

28%

17%

29%

30%

28%

Monthly

10%

16%

10%

15%

10% 53%

15%

14%

14%

9% 52%

14%

10%

12%

Rarely/ Never

50% 25% 11%

40%

23%

15%

33%

26%

13%

28%

Pay to download media Download free media Watch short videos Read online magazine

Note: GCC = Bahrain, Kuwait, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, and the UAE; Levant = Lebanon and Jordan; North Africa = Egypt and Algeria. Source: Booz & Company– Google Arab Digital Generation survey 2012

14

Strategy&

Across all regions, more than 40 percent of users watch short videos online for entertainment at least once a day, and often more frequently. YouTube usage in MENA countries is a striking example of access to venues of entertainment. With 167 million playbacks per day and 100 percent yearover-year playback growth, MENA countries — and Saudi Arabia in particular — stand as the highest users of YouTube as a percentage of the total Internet population (see Exhibit 3).

Exhibit 3 The ADG loves YouTube
Percentage of YouTube Users in Total Internet Population, 2012

85%

83% 76% 74% 70% 63% 30% 15% 15% 21% 63% 58% 12%

42%

34%

21%

43%

49%

55% 44%

55%

48%

42%

46%

Saudi Arabia Daily users Other users

UAE

Spain

Egypt

U.K.

France

Italy

Germany

Note: “Other users” refers to people who view YouTube videos on a weekly, monthly, or less frequent basis. Source: Enumeration Study 2012, TNS

Strategy&

15

The Internet has clearly overtaken TV as the must-have technology for the ADG. When faced with a clear alternative between living without TV (most popular option in the MENA region) or without the Internet, nearly 80 percent said they would give up television. That decline is no longer a hypothetical scenario for other traditional media; increased reliance on digital technology has led to reduced consumption of traditional media even beyond that of global benchmarks (see Exhibit 4, page 17). Roughly 85 percent of the ADG now spend less than one hour a day with print media. The ADG is also relatively uninterested in online magazines. This may be due to a lack of trust in such content, or because the ADG believes there is not enough quality material available in Arabic. Whatever the reason, the result is potentially impoverishing at both a cultural and linguistic level. If people do not read online content, then others will not produce it, and the relative lack of Arabic content on the Web could become a negative, selfreinforcing trend. Professional, academic, and personal activities About 28 percent of the ADG use the Internet for professional reasons, such as email and business-related online search activities. What is particularly striking is that although the ADG is the best educated and most ambitious generation the region has yet produced, it rarely uses the Internet for education purposes. This is not for lack of desire or interest from the ADG’s side. We know that youth in the region are seeking more technologically enhanced forms of education that will help them obtain employment and fulfill their goals. Rather, the fault lies with the education sector, which thus far has not provided the access or the Arabic digital content that this demographic craves. There is a clear need across the region to improve the quality and job relevance of education, with technology a critical tool for delivering pedagogical content (see the section entitled “Survey results regarding education,” page 48).

16

Strategy&

Exhibit 4 ADG Internet access exceeds traditional media usage
Time Spent on Media, and Frequency of Access

TV 60% Daily 17% 63% 5–6 Days a Week 3–4 Days a Week 12% 58% 17% 24% 25% 22% 56% 62%

Radio 67% 34% 5% 60% 34% 10% 54% 54% 10%

Print

Internet 70%

30% 3% 1%

29%

52% 31% 9% 2% 71% 41% 6% 6%

46%

36%

23%

Less than 30 min 30 min to 3 hours More than 3 hours TV Global View (in minutes) 242 212 223 246 283 234 196 189 179 182 Radio 166 266 159 U.S. 108 Spain Ireland Ø 178

Ø 234

U.K. France Germany Italy

U.S.

Spain Ireland

U.K. France Germany Italy

Source: Ofcom, “International Communications Market 2011”; Booz & Company– Google Arab Digital Generation survey 2012

Strategy&

17

Respondents across clusters also spend significantly less time (9 percent) on the Internet for personal activities such as paying bills. This low usage level for commerce is apparent across the MENA region but more so in the Levant (Lebanon and Jordan in our survey) and North Africa (Egypt and Algeria in our survey), where it is significantly lower than international standards (see Exhibit 5, page 19). This seems to relate to a lack of confidence in settlements systems and digital security, as reflected in under use of the Internet for purchases (see the section entitled “The Private Sector,” page 41). Platforms used to access the Internet Internet access devices are widespread among the ADG, yet the preference in platforms is shifting. Although computers are ubiquitous in the region, the ADG increasingly relies on portable devices such as smartphones, tablet computers, and laptops to get on the Internet (see Exhibit 6, page 20). These devices are so prevalent that any deprivation leads to functional disadvantage and emotional discomfort. During the focus group sessions, a “what if” scenario of temporary Internet deprivation elicited anxieties from young respondents. A teenage female from Jordan described not having Internet access as akin to “walking without shoes.” Another respondent from Saudi Arabia related, “Once I forgot my mobile and went out [and] I didn’t enjoy my outing. Even though it was a party, all I kept thinking about was who had called my phone or sent me a message.” This is in line with findings in other parts of the world. Among younger Europeans, 52 percent say they feel disconnected from the world if they don’t have their mobile phones with them, and 91 percent of mobile phone users keep their phones less than a meter away, waking or sleeping.10

18

Strategy&

Exhibit 5 The ADG is still hesitant to buy online
Frequency of Online Commercial Activities

Online Banking Global1 Usage: Daily 10%, Weekly 19%, Monthly 15%, GCC Rarely/Never 56% Daily

Levant

North Africa

10%

3%

3%

9%

3%

3%

5%

0%

0%

Weekly

18%

16%

16%

14%

12%

10%

8%

11%

12%

Monthly

16%

9%

11%

11%

10%

7% 81%

9% 78%

5% 84%

8% 80%

Rarely/ Never

56%

72%

71%

66%

75%

Access online banking Make a purchase online with credit card Make a purchase online with cash on delivery

1

As indicated by averages of Australia, Colombia, Hungary, Mexico, New Zealand, Sweden, Taiwan, U.K., U.S. (2009). Source: Booz & Company– Google Arab Digital Generation survey 2012

Strategy&

19

Exhibit 6 The ADG has many Internet access devices
Access Devices by Sub-Region

GCC 60% One Device 26% 7% 8% 34%

Levant 58% 6% 68%

North Africa

30% 2% 0% 1%

Two Devices

41% 16% 9%

33%

44% 24% 3% 29%

44%

40% 2% 14%

Three Devices

20%

32%

19%

28%

28%

33% 7%

32%

32%

33% 6%

30%

Desktop computer Laptop/netbook Tablet computer Smartphone

Source: Booz & Company– Google Arab Digital Generation survey 2012

20

Strategy&

That said, there are clear differences within the region, and between the region and the rest of the world, in smartphone penetration. Smartphones are popular in the more affluent GCC, which has usage levels similar to those of developed markets. By contrast, in the Levant and North Africa the adoption of smartphones is less extensive (see Exhibit 7).

Exhibit 7 The ADG in the GCC and Levant follow global trends in device preferences
Access to Devices

GCC 81% ADG’s Access to Devices 46% 61% 36% 52%

Levant 77% 46% 12% 75%

North Africa

53% 21% 6%

Global Access (2011 unit shipments, in millions)

420 150 225 60

Smartphones are significantly more popular globally than in the MENA region

Desktop computer Laptop/netbook Tablet computer Smartphone

Source: Econsultancy, “Internet Statistics Compendium” (Global), February 2012; Booz & Company–Google Arab Digital Generation survey 2012

Strategy&

21

For the ADG the home remains the most common location from which to connect. Indeed, in North Africa 83 percent of the ADG get online from their place of residence. Connecting “on the move” is also popular, particularly in the GCC and the Levant, where such access exceeds the global average (see Exhibit 8).

Exhibit 8 On-the-go Internet access is higher in the GCC and Levant than the global average

Where and How the Internet Is Accessed

GCC 65% Place 20% 9% 70% 53%

Levant 75%

North Africa 83%

22%

28% 9% 13%

17%

On the move At home Public spaces Internet cafes Internet Access by Smartphone or Wireless Computer Channels Used to Access Email 48% World Population with Internet at Home

Global view

52% 8%

49%

37% 19% U.K.

51% Ø 36% U.S. 18% Mobile

35%

33%

Sweden Australia Hungary New Zealand

Desktop Webmail

Home

Source: World Internet Project (WIP) 2012; Booz & Company–Google Arab Digital Generation survey 2012.

22

Strategy&

Psychographics Digital technology is a liberating force for the ADG. For example, 63 percent of respondents believe that they should be able to do what they want as long as it does not negatively affect other people. At the same time, far fewer (37 percent) feel that they are able to express their opinions freely without fear of the consequences. This is even more the case in the GCC, where just 29 percent said they felt free to express their opinion (see Exhibit 9).

Exhibit 9 The ADG wants more flexibility and freedom
Respondents’ Views on Freedom

61%

65%

68%

46%

46%

43%

45% 40%

44%

45%

47%

29%

It is important that my work/ education is flexible in terms of when and where I work/study

I should be able to do what I want as long as it does not affect other people

I make my own decisions, even if others disagree

I can express my opinions freely without fear of the consequences

GCC Levant North Africa

Source: Booz & Company– Google Arab Digital Generation survey 2012

Strategy&

23

These psychographics — the simultaneous notions of freedom and frustration — have clear effects on how the ADG relates to the state and to businesses. The result is a relative lack of ADG engagement with both government figures and corporate entities. There is a wariness among the ADG about perceived existing structures that limit its options when compared to the free-form anonymity of life online, where everything seems possible. The ADG wants to connect, it wants to talk to its governments, purchase from businesses, and use technology for healthcare, but it needs to feel comfortable and reassured in these interactions. A majority of the ADG acknowledges the role of technology in enabling freedom of speech. Most use the Internet to voice their opinions and to express their feelings in an unfettered manner. They can say things online that they are unable to say elsewhere. They tend to use pseudonyms or nicknames to share their honest thoughts/ideas — and to protect themselves from the consequences. As one male respondent from Saudi Arabia put it, “For me, on the Internet, I might use a pseudonym and express my honest opinion and break all limits.” And as a young Saudi female respondent proclaimed, “We used to feel weak in front of males, but not anymore. Now we are free to express our opinions.” In addition, members of the ADG say they base their life decisions on their own opinions, more than on those of traditional structures such as religious institutions. On average, 42 percent make their own decisions, even if others disagree.11 More than half said that they should be free to choose their own career or education path based on their personal interests, rather than on the influence of others (see Exhibit 10, page 25). (Notably, this percentage is higher among the younger half of the sample, at 57 percent of those ages 15 to 24, compared to 46 percent of those ages 25 to 35.) “Technology helps you make choices,” one man from the UAE said in a focus group. “There’s nothing that’s forced on you. You can say no, I want this and I don’t want that. Everything is in front of you.”

24

Strategy&

Exhibit 10 The ADG wants to define its life choices
Respondents on their Approach to Personal Decisions

65% 56% 49% 52% 40% 43% 43% 46%

62%

I prefer the things I own to be customized to meet my needs GCC Levant North Africa

I prefer to modify the way things are done rather than follow a certain way of doing things

It is important that I can choose a career/education that interests me rather than being led by my grades

Source: Booz & Company– Google Arab Digital Generation survey 2012

Strategy&

25

26

Strategy&

The impact of the ADG on the MENA region
The ADG and its reliance on communications technology will have a profound effect on the MENA region. This section discusses the specific impacts on society and on institutions in the realms of government, the private sector, education, and healthcare. The ADG appreciates the power of technology and wants to be heard. It is, however, tentative in its approach to how it engages with a range of institutions. This wariness is not rejection; rather, it is the ADG’s signal that it seeks reassurance and that it wants to build connections that relate to its ambitious and educated approach to life. As Strategy& has discovered in previous studies, young people in the MENA region want more — and want to contribute more — than previous generations were able to.12 Impact on society At its most basic level, the Internet has transformed the way that people meet and interact with each other. It has also brought paradoxes to communication. People now have networks of 300 or 400 social and professional contacts whom they routinely connect with around the world. Yet they rarely have face-to-face conversations with these people. Indeed, they have never met most of them. Some feel that this has an isolating effect, in that people spend more time communicating online and less time speaking face-to-face. These effects have been accelerating thanks to the impact of social media, an area in which the MENA region is catching up fast. For example, Facebook and Twitter have become the most popular social networks in the region, as they have around the world. Although there are not many Arabonly social networks, a few exceptions stand out. Specifically, Aywaa.com is a social network that supports a user interface similar to that of Facebook. Yallatunes.com supports peer-to-peer sharing of Arabic songs and video clips. The communication features of these sites are rendering the telephone — and even email — less relevant for socializing. The societal shifts among the ADG have come in three principal areas: communication with friends and family, marriage, and religion.
Strategy& 27

The ADG appreciates the power of technology and wants to be heard. It is, however, tentative in its approach to how it engages with a range of institutions.

Communication with friends and family The survey results indicate that members of the ADG have less direct personal contact with their family and friends, as technology increasingly provides them with communication alternatives. To an extent, this distancing also enables the ADG’s more independent spirit when it comes to making decisions and choosing individual life paths. Among specific quantitative results, some 44 percent say that they spend less time meeting close friends face-to-face and more time communicating with them online or over the phone, compared with around a third (34 percent) who disagree with this claim. Interestingly, this is more true of females (48 percent agreed with this statement) than males (41 percent). Only 31 percent of the ADG say they actually make telephone calls to their friends. In comparison, 55 percent call their family members. When communicating with friends, members of the ADG primarily use instant messenger platforms, text messages, online chat, and social network messaging; email is seen as formal and even outdated. At least one in two members of the ADG believes that parents are unable to keep up with the younger generation when it comes to technology, and that traditional values are being diluted as society is becoming more connected via the Internet. Another aspect of the change in society is the evolution of language. Respondents perceive that by spending so much time on the Internet — where English is the universal language — they are losing touch with their native language. At least two in five ADG members claim to use both Arabic and English to search the Internet. The qualitative results support these findings. Most participants in the survey’s focus groups felt that digital technology has improved their social connections to friends and family. “I’m very much interested in using social networking websites like Facebook and Twitter,” said one man from the UAE. “Bringing every kind of social group together in one place and letting them interact is really a big thing indeed.” Yet some voice a concern that too much time spent online is changing society in less positive ways. “I feel so much of these technologies are imposed on us rather than being chosen by us,” said a male from Jordan. “There are many technologies (even Facebook) that I don’t recall how I ended up using. Everyone else starts using it so you become alienated unless you use it.” A female from Jordan echoed this, speculating about a future in which technology becomes even more ever-present: “Life will not be nice,” she said. “People will just stay at home or walk in the streets playing with their smartphones or laptops. There will be less interaction or real relationships between people.”

At least one in two members of the ADG believes that parents are unable to keep up with the younger generation when it comes to technology, and that traditional values are being diluted as society is becoming more connected via the Internet.

28

Strategy&

Marriage Technology is also changing perceptions of marriage, as the survey results indicate. Among married members of the ADG, a majority of respondents in the GCC had an arranged marriage, especially in Saudi Arabia (64 percent), Kuwait (54 percent), the UAE (51 percent), and Qatar (46 percent). However, the survey results show this pattern is shifting. Among those not yet married, respondents were asked what type of marriage they would prefer, and less than a third said they want an arranged marriage (see Exhibit 11). Even among those who are still

Exhibit 11 Traditional marriages are strong in some regions; singles want to be able to choose
Types of Marriages Among Married ADG Members Single ADG Members’ Marriage Preferences

60% 52% 51%

63%

50% 44% 42%

28% 23% 19% 16% 23% 19% 22%

31%

28%

7%

7%

Arranged marriage (by family consent) GCC Levant North Africa

Love marriage (personal choice)

Arranged love marriage (personal choice with family consent)

Arranged marriage (by family consent)

Love marriage (personal choice)

Arranged love marriage (personal choice with family consent)

Source: Booz & Company– Google Arab Digital Generation survey 2012

Strategy&

29

marrying through traditional approaches, members of the ADG now have the opportunity to research the other person online — and many do. A striking example of changing views about marriage protocol is the survey response about whether it is acceptable to marry a person whom the respondent had met online. More than 60 percent in North Africa and the Levant approve of a male member of their family marrying a woman whom he had met online, with the GCC approval rate 44 percent. In this regard, the region is also narrowing the gap with other countries, where online dating is far more prevalent, and now represents a US$1 billion industry worldwide. Surprisingly, there were high rates of approval for a woman finding her prospective husband online, even if the rates were lower than those for men — 55 percent in North Africa and the Levant approved this, along with 41 percent in the GCC. We assume that these “positive” responses are based on the premise that the online forum is only for the initial introduction and screening, and that potential spouses still then proceed through the conventional processes of evaluating each other’s personalities and social compatibility before formalizing the relationship. “Meeting through social network sites or even marriage sites for the sake of simply getting introduced to each other is good,” said one Egyptian male. “But later, they need to meet in real life. They need to give themselves a chance to know each other in person to understand their personalities.” However, others voiced overt skepticism over the concept of even meeting a potential spouse online. “Recently, marriage websites have grown a lot and claim to be based on Islamic beliefs,” said one UAE man. “My opinion is that it’s a waste of time and a trap. It is false and does not belong to our customs and traditions.” A woman from Jordan was similarly negative. “The new method of meeting partners is the Internet,” she said. “But when you think about it, it is so weird. You don’t know this person. How do you know his intentions? How do you know he’s not lying?” Religion The final major societal shift driven by the ADG is in religion, where the region’s strong culture and heritage is evolving rapidly. Virtually all religious figures now have blogs. This provides lay people with access to different schools of thought and effectively removes the hierarchical aspect of religious discourse. Yet, contrary to popular wisdom, many respondents feel that this aspect of the Internet has reinforced their faith. The vast majority of respondents (approximately 70 percent) reported that technology allowed them to explore the various facets of religion through websites. Although some noted that the Internet exposed people to immoral content, or made them question their faith, roughly three

Surprisingly, there were high rates of approval for a woman finding her prospective husband online, even if the rates were lower than those for men.

30

Strategy&

times as many held that the Internet exposed them to religious content that increased their religious knowledge and strengthened their faith. “Technology helps me in the search for [answers to] questions that spring up in my mind,” said an Emirati female. A male from Egypt voiced similar experiences. “TV channels and the Internet helped me to develop and consolidate my religious faith; now I see the religious channels and look for opinions and communicate with religious leaders.”

Strategy&

31

Such impact on religion is more dominant in the GCC and North Africa than in the Levant (see Exhibit 12). Overall, however, the ADG is again ploughing its own furrow, as it remains connected to the traditions of its forebears in its own independent and technologically driven way. This stands in contradiction to the rest of the world, where for the overwhelming majority the Internet has not affected their religious beliefs.13

Exhibit 12 The Internet brings the ADG closer to religion
Internet Technology and Religious Beliefs

GCC Impact of technology on religion 74% 26% 63%

Levant 74% 37%

North Africa 26%

Brings me closer to my religion Takes me away from my religion 74% Content exposure 26% 35% 65% 33% 67%

Unreligious, immoral content that religion forbids Religious content that increases my knowledge 80% 20% 26% 74% 20% 80%

Content alignment with beliefs

Contradicts my beliefs/ makes me question my faith Allows me to endorse my beliefs and strengthens my faith

Source: Booz & Company– Google Arab Digital Generation survey 2012

32

Strategy&

Recommendations
These shifts in cultural and social mores, driven by technology, may result in less desirable outcomes if they are not managed properly. For example, the Arabic language is already under pressure in the virtual world — whereas Arabic speakers represent 5 percent of the world’s population and are growing at a faster rate than those of many other languages, online Arabic content is less than 1 percent of the total.14 Similarly, given the religiosity of the ADG, leaders in the region need to take proper care to ensure that the extremist views that have challenged the region over past decades are not rekindled through lack of guidance and awareness. Regarding language, regional leaders can devote more resources to creating Arabic digital content that is meaningful, interesting, and educational for the ADG. For example, the King Abdullah Initiative for Arabic Content aims to focus on digital content, infrastructure development, and Arabization, among other goals. Similarly, the UAE’s twofour54 initiative, overseen by the Abu Dhabi government and intended to create an Arabic media and entertainment industry for the MENA region, is another example of efforts to preserve and develop the Arabic and Islamic heritage.15 Such initiatives generate Arabic material that engages with the members of the ADG and that is created by them, as opposed to what the increasingly obsolete “old” media of print, radio, and TV do, which is broadcasting to them. Regarding other issues such as religion, policymakers can embrace the religiosity of the ADG and use it for socially and economically productive activities. This entails fostering an understanding of religion that is exciting and empowering in a productive and constructive manner — away from extremist, destructive views that have threatened regional stability by exploiting vulnerable young minds. Indeed, the Internet can be used to spread religious tolerance and open-mindedness among members of the ADG, who stand apart from others through their education level and sophistication.

Strategy&

33

Impact on institutions In addition to its effect on society, the ADG will influence institutions in the MENA region in four principal areas — government, the private sector, education, and healthcare. Government As noted earlier, regional governments have taken strong steps to digitize their societies, through infrastructure investments and by introducing competitive forces to the delivery of telecom services. Yet regional governments have yet to use digital tools to actively engage their constituents. The ADG expects social media to be transparent, crowdsourced, and responsive. However, the engagement efforts of some governments to date have been slow, hierarchical, and unresponsive.16 The events of the Arab Spring underscore this phenomenon, as many among the ADG have become quite outspoken about the issues they face and the progressive changes they expect (see Exhibit 13, page 35). Usage patterns during that period show that social media played a significant role in helping citizens organize. Facebook subscriptions in the region increased an average of 30 percent between January and April 2011. In Egypt and Tunisia, the number of daily tweets peaked with an increase of 140 percent and 160 percent, respectively, between January 1 and mid-March 2011.17 Although those events led to significant political upheaval, their technological aspect is in line with similar — though less disruptive — shifts around the world, as an increasingly educated and digital population has begun demanding greater accountability from the state, and leaders have responded by becoming more connected and more transparent. The Internet has allowed politicians to communicate their positions to the public, to outline and explain their goals, and to build loyalty and confidence in their leadership. The Obama administration, for example, created the White House White Board to put out videos on YouTube to better explain its policies. At the same time, President Barack Obama and his presidential rival, former Governor Mitt Romney, are augmenting their presidential campaigns by hosting video chats on the Google+ social network to connect with voters and answer their questions. In the MENA region, while there is still much work to do, some national governments have made strides in this area. In Egypt, for example, the Internet was a critical tool for streamlining the voting process during the recent presidential election. Google established a portal specifically for the election, featuring information about the individual political parties running for posts, as well as information on major issues such as the economy, education, foreign relations, and social justice. Visitors could even look up the location of their individual polling stations.
34 Strategy&

Exhibit 13 The ADG feels regional governments have a range of problems
Respondents’ Views on Government

71% 62%

66% 57%

60% 51%

45% 55%

50% 53%

40% 42%

29% 37%

36% 39%

29%

28%

29%

26%

28%

30% 35%

17% 25%

36% Lack of democratic rights Misuse of authority 35 25%

16% 20% 10%

16% 25% 17%

20%

13%

Large rich-poor divide

Ethnic discrimination

Gender discrimination

Lack of safety and security

14%

Mistreatment of labor force

Lack of infrastructure

Lack of transparency

Corruption

GCC Levant North Africa

Poor state healthcare

Lack of leadership

Source: Booz & Company– Google Arab Digital Generation survey 2012

Similarly, Saudi Arabia established the King Abdul Aziz Center for National Dialogue in 2003 to encourage communication among Saudis and has now added technology to its tools for citizen engagement. In September 2011, the center conducted a TV interview with the Saudi minister of education, His Highness Prince Faisal bin Abdullah, including live questions submitted from the public via Facebook. Some MENA leaders are in constant touch with citizens through social media venues. In the UAE, Sheikh Mohammed Bin Rashid Al-Maktoum, the vice president of the UAE and prime minister and ruler of Dubai, has over a million followers on Twitter, a platform he uses to take on daily questions from the UAE and around the world in Arabic and English.

Strategy&

Violation of human rights

19%

60% 57%

E-Government services Another equally important function of governments today is the provision of online public services for constituents, such as payment of bills and fines, commercial registrations, visa-related transactions, and the like. These e-government programs help reduce cost, provide international competitiveness for the economy, and can lay the ground for national technological development.18 Indeed, the future prosperity of nations is tied to digitization of their economies,19 and e-government, and several MENA countries have developed notable initiatives. A recent United Nations e-government survey of 190 countries found that the six nations of the GCC lead other countries of the Middle East in terms of e-government services. The UAE ranked first in the Arab world (28th overall), followed by Bahrain (36th), Saudi Arabia (41st), and Qatar (48th). Levant countries such as Lebanon and Jordan ranked in the middle of the pack, and other Arab countries in North Africa such as Morocco and Algeria were in the bottom 30 percent.20 In seeking to implement better e-government services, clear challenges remain for policymakers across all of the Arab world, but particularly for countries in the Levant and North Africa. These challenges include underutilization of e-services compared with traditional services. (Although the ADG has expressed a clear demand for e-government, it is ahead of the overall population in many of these countries.) There is also insufficient public awareness about the availability and security of such services, among other factors. The survey results support this. For example, online payment of government services or fines is widely available in GCC countries. Despite this, 42 percent of the ADG in GCC countries are seemingly unaware that such services are available. This is more so for the older ADG age group in the GCC. About 49 percent of those between the ages of 25 and 35 were not aware of the provision of such services.21 Survey results regarding government Interestingly, respondents do not put regional governments at the top of the list regarding sectors in need of ICT improvement. Of six possible options, government was lowest on the list, behind healthcare, education, energy/utilities, financial services, and public transportation. In other words, governments do not require major restructuring in order to better meet the needs of the ADG. Rather, they simply need to leverage existing technology in more strategic ways, to provide services more effectively and better engage with constituents. For example, respondents want an online platform to connect with political leaders. Interestingly, despite their near-constant contact with friends online, the majority of ADG members have not used any online platform to connect with their government leaders. Yet many say they would use such a service if it
36 Strategy&

were available. More than half of Egyptian respondents (56 percent) said that they are likely to use such a service, compared with 28 percent in Algeria. The main prospective use for such a platform is to give a suggestion (cited by 43 percent of respondents), to voice opinions about political or social matters (39 percent), or to compliment the leadership (29 percent). Given that many of these reasons are benign, why hasn’t the ADG made more concerted efforts to use the government communication platforms that are in place? The main reason cited is a lack of trust in their leaders (see Exhibit 14, page 38). Similarly, other ADG members simply do not consider the political environment conducive to an honest and forthright discussion. The qualitative results support this. “We weren’t able to criticize any public figure or authority, because one word from them could ruin our lives,” said one Egyptian male during a focus group. “After the revolution, we’re freer to object and voice our opinion.” Although that perception of potential consequences for those who speak out still lingers in parts of the region, others among the ADG understand the role that social media has played in fostering political change thus far. “The Egyptian revolution was through the Internet,” said a female from Egypt. “If these sites did not exist, there would not have been any revolution.” That role will continue, with or without the acquiescence of governments. “Technology helps political activists by spreading their thoughts. It reduces their suppression,” said an Egyptian male from the 15 to 25 years of age bracket. Governments must understand this force, and leverage it to beneficial purposes. While the rapid shifts of technology among the ADG represent a potential disruption to all governments, it is worth noting that the ADG is markedly idealistic and hopeful for the future. Its members do not seek to agitate and create political change for its own sake. Rather, like other youth populations around the world, they want to use technology — or any other tools at hand — to improve living conditions for themselves and their fellow citizens. This sentiment was summed up by a female focus group participant from the UAE. “I would like to be part of the change in the future, because I want to participate in my country’s improvement and development,” she said. “I want to provide and share my knowledge and skills to help my country attain the highest level of prosperity and progress.” Furthermore, respondents expressed a strong demand for e-government services, with varying priorities among countries. Among Egyptian respondents, the top preference is an online capability to report corrupt practices (cited by 64 percent of that country’s survey participants). As one Egyptian male put it, “Provide a service that delivers complaints to the proper authorities, instead of going through the usual bureaucratic process.” In addition, survey respondents want an online application to
Strategy& 37

Exhibit 14 ADG communication with leadership must be strengthened
Reasons for Lack of Communication with Public Officials

45% 46% 39% 33% 29% 30% 35% 34% 32% 24% 19% 16% 16% 9% 6% 6% 19% 37%

Lack of trust in the leaders

Fear of being targeted for saying the truth or voicing one’s opinion

GCC Levant North Africa

Lack of action or Do not consider the environment conducive accountability which makes voicing one’s to speaking against opinion redundant certain individuals or groups

Fear of backlash from others online, bloggers etc.

Other

Source: Booz & Company– Google Arab Digital Generation survey 2012

register vehicles (cited by 42 percent of Emiratis), and an online ID service (the most sought-after application across the region, cited by 57 percent of respondents) (see Exhibit 15, page 39). Improve public services: With enhanced communication, citizens are better able to interact with public agencies to improve public services. In the U.K., a program known as “Love Clean Streets” provides a free smartphone application and website to enable people to report on visual and environmental pollution such as graffiti, potholes, and garbage. Citizens can take a photo from their mobile phones, specify the location, send it to their local authority, and track the government’s progress as the problem gets fixed. In Egypt, a website called “Zabatak” (Arabic for “gotcha”) allows citizens to fight crime and corruption by reporting on theft, bribes, corruption, and other social ills. These reports are forwarded to the authorities, and consolidated for the public to see where such incidents are taking place.
38 Strategy&

56% 61% 55%
0%

Strategy& ID applications (e.g., passport, national ID, driver’s license) GCC Levant North Africa Tax filing 32% 30% 37% 41% 42% 52% 47% 44% 50% 42% 43% 51% 47% 40% 39% 33% 46% 52% 48% 44% 51% 56% 33% 43% 39% 27% Reporting on child labor practices 41% 36% Applications for marriage, birth, death registration Online payment of fees for services and fines Application for car/ vehicle registration Complaints and comments to various government departments Applications for commercial licenses, permits, and approvals Reporting on malpractice (by doctors, food manufacturers, pharmaceutical companies, etc.) Reporting on corruption in the public and private sectors Reporting on violence against women and children 41%

Desired E-government Services

Exhibit 15 The ADG wants e-government services

Source: Booz & Company– Google Arab Digital Generation survey 2012

39

Recommendations
Digital technology is increasing the expectations of transparency and accountability from government bodies and officials. These expectations will likely gain momentum over time and across countries. There are four main venues for government agencies or representatives to connect with their citizens: • Humanize political engagement: A first step is to soften the rigid image of political engagement that is alienating the ADG. Citizens want to know the person behind the position. The Internet represents a valuable opportunity to build citizens’ trust by removing barriers and making political figures more accessible. For example, Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper has a sizable presence on Google+. Facilitate transparency: Politicians can also use the Internet to interact directly with their constituencies, solicit their opinions on legislative issues, and increase government transparency. In Kenya, for example, the minister of finance published a draft version of the national budget for 2011–2012 on Facebook to outline Kenya’s budgetary priorities. Citizens reacted overwhelmingly positively with feedback, comments, and suggestions. In Iceland, the government sought public feedback while revising the constitution; and in Morocco, residents weighed in on a constitutional amendment. Improve public services: With enhanced communication, citizens are better able to interact with public agencies to improve public services. In the U.K., a program known as “Love Clean Streets” provides a free smartphone application and website to enable people to report on visual and environmental pollution such as graffiti, potholes, and garbage. Citizens can take a photo from their mobile phones, specify the location, send it to their local authority, and track the government’s progress as the problem gets fixed. In Egypt, a website called “Zabatak” (Arabic for “gotcha”) allows citizens to fight crime and corruption by reporting on theft, bribes, corruption, and other social ills. These reports are forwarded to the authorities, and consolidated for the public to see where such incidents are taking place. • Develop e-government services: Finally, countries in the region need to develop an appropriate model for the implementation of e-government. A couple of key points can facilitate this development. First, governments must ensure that the requisite sponsorship, commitment, and support are in place at the highest possible levels of political leadership. Second, agencies should develop a clear strategy to facilitate e-government service usage and ensure its security, focusing on the needs of the various constituent segments — mainly citizens (such as issuing driver’s licenses and other forms of identification), businesses (simplifying the commercial registration process), other government entities (sharing data in a more streamlined fashion), and employees (e.g., administering pension services).





Operationally, the government must prioritize e-government efforts by looking at its entire portfolio of services, clustering them by common service themes, and focusing on the largest service gaps and highest-demand services first. Finally, governments should leverage all possible means to increase public awareness of e-government services, including social media, text messages, emails, advertising, and any other available tools — digital and otherwise.

40

Strategy&

The private sector